Voting Receivers and Comparators

MCN and BRSC Monitoring · Last updated · About 2 min read

A repeater's downlink (repeater-to-radio) range is often much larger than a portable or mobile radio's uplink (radio-to-repeater) range, because the repeater transmits at much higher power than a handheld can. This creates "dead spots" where a user can hear the repeater fine but the repeater can't hear them back.

How Voting Solves It

The fix is to deploy multiple remote voting receivers at different locations around the coverage area (in addition to the main repeater site), each listening independently for the same uplink signal, and feed all of their received audio into a central device called a comparator (informally, a "voter"). When a radio transmits, some or all of the remote receivers un-squelch and pick it up; the comparator compares the quality of each receiver's copy of the audio in real time and automatically selects ("votes for") the cleanest one to forward to the repeater's transmitter — the dispatcher or listener hears only the best copy, without knowing which physical receiver won the vote. See Comparators for a deeper technical dive into exactly how that quality comparison and switching decision is made.

Voting Receivers Specifically

A voting receiver is deliberately simple compared to a full repeater: since it only needs to listen, it typically requires no transmitter and no local antenna large enough to also transmit — just a sensitive receiver and antenna placed to fill a specific coverage gap (e.g. a low-lying area, a valley, or the far edge of the intended coverage footprint where portables are known to be "heard but can't hear back"). Because a voting receiver has no transmit duties, it can often be sited more cheaply and in more locations than a full duplex repeater site would require, making voting an economical way to extend uplink coverage without building out additional full repeater infrastructure.

Getting Audio Back to the Comparator

Remote receiver sites need a way to deliver their audio back to the central comparator; common links include IP/network connections, microwave, fiber, leased telephone twisted-pair circuits, or a dedicated RF link — the same categories of backhaul discussed in IP Networking in Two-Way Radio Systems and Dish Antennas and Point-to-Point Links.

References

See also: CTI product documentation

This article is part of the CTI Products Knowledge Base. Questions about RadioPro or MCN products? Call +1 (513) 595-5900 or email info@ctiproducts.com.

Informational only. This article is general background and is not engineering, safety, legal or regulatory advice. Verify requirements with the equipment manufacturer and the applicable authority before relying on it. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.