Switches, Routers, and Hubs
The Three Devices, One Sentence Each
- A hub (obsolete) repeats every incoming bit out every port — one shared collision domain, no intelligence.
- A switch forwards Ethernet frames only to the port where the destination MAC address lives, by maintaining a learned MAC-address table — the building block of every modern LAN.
- A router forwards packets between networks using IP addresses and a routing table — the device that connects subnets, sites, and the internet to each other.
The layer distinction is the durable mental model: hubs are layer 1 (bits), switches layer 2 (frames/MACs), routers layer 3 (packets/IPs). Many real boxes blur roles — "layer-3 switches" route between VLANs, and the typical site "router" bundles routing, firewall, NAT, and sometimes DHCP in one appliance (e.g., the Juniper SRX units in ASTRO 25 site roles, or the GGM 8000).
Behaviors That Matter for Radio-System Networks
- Broadcast domains: switches forward broadcasts to every port; routers stop them. That boundary defines where DHCP discovery, ARP, and other broadcast mechanisms reach — and why subnetting/VLANs exist to keep domains small.
- Multicast needs help: a basic switch floods multicast like broadcast; IGMP snooping-capable switches deliver it only to subscribed ports — the difference behind "multicast-based features misbehave on the cheap switch" (see Unicast, Broadcast, and Multicast). Radio-site infrastructure generally deserves managed switches for exactly these serviceability features — consistent with the enterprise-grade models documented at ASTRO 25 core sites.
- Full duplex killed the collision: switched full-duplex links have no collisions; the residual gotcha is the duplex mismatch (one side forced, one auto-negotiating) that passes pings but shreds voice — already flagged in Troubleshooting RoIP and Gateway Connectivity.
Why Hubs Still Get Mentioned
Purely as contrast and history — and one niche: an old hub (or a modern managed switch's mirror port, the better tool) lets a technician see all segment traffic for capture. If a "hub" is found in a production radio network today, replacing it is free performance and sanity.
Related Pages
See also: CTI product documentation
This article is part of the CTI Products Knowledge Base. Questions about RadioPro or MCN products? Call +1 (513) 595-5900 or email info@ctiproducts.com.
Informational only. This article is general background and is not engineering, safety, legal or regulatory advice. Verify requirements with the equipment manufacturer and the applicable authority before relying on it. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.