Audio Clipping: What It Is, What It Sounds Like and How to Fix It
Audio clipping explained with a computed waveform and harmonic-distortion chart: what causes harsh, distorted radio audio, how to find the stage that clips, and how to set levels.
Clipping happens when an audio signal is asked to be louder than a circuit, converter or file format can carry. The tops of the waves are cut off flat. The result is harsh, buzzy, "crunchy" audio that cannot be repaired afterward, because the part of the wave that was cut off is gone. It is one of the most common causes of bad audio in radio-to-IP and dispatch installations, and it is entirely preventable by setting levels correctly. For the wider topic of signal levels, balanced wiring and impedance see audio-levels-and-radio-interfacing.
What clipping does to a waveform
Every audio path has a ceiling. In digital audio it is digital full scale, written 0 dBFS (decibels relative to full scale; see Decibels): the largest value a sample can hold. A signal below the ceiling is passed unchanged. A signal that tries to go above it is flattened at the ceiling.
In the left panel a tone peaks at half of full scale (−6 dBFS), leaving headroom, and the wave is a clean sine. In the middle panel the same tone is only slightly too loud: its peaks are just 1.2 dB over full scale, so the tops are shaved off, and the wave spends a good part of each cycle at the limit. In the right panel it is 12 dB too loud, and the signal is almost a square wave. The dashed line shows what the signal would have been; the solid line with the orange flat sections is what actually gets through.
Why it sounds bad: added harmonics
A pure tone contains one frequency. A flattened wave contains that frequency plus new frequencies at whole-number multiples of it (harmonics) that were never in the original. For a symmetrical clip like this, they are the odd harmonics: 3, 5, 7, 9 times the original frequency. The bar chart shows them for a 1 kHz tone, and the table gives the values.
| Case | Time at the limit | 3rd harmonic | 5th | 7th | 9th | Total harmonic distortion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Healthy level (peak at −6 dBFS) | 0% | none | none | none | none | 0% |
| Slightly clipped (peak 1.2 dB over full scale) | 29% | -26.6 dB | -30.7 dB | -38.9 dB | -58.9 dB | 5.7% |
| Heavily clipped (peak 12 dB over full scale) | 88% | -10.2 dB | -16.1 dB | -21.5 dB | -27.8 dB | 35.9% |
Even slight clipping adds a third harmonic about 27 dB below the tone. That is audible on speech as roughness, and it gets worse quickly with level: at 12 dB over, the third harmonic is only 10 dB below the tone and the total harmonic distortion is about 36%. These figures come from a computed example (a 1 kHz sine, hard-limited and analyzed with a Fourier transform); real speech is more complex, but the effect is the same.
What clipping sounds like
- Harsh, raspy or "crackling" voice, especially on loud talkers or when someone shouts or is close to the microphone.
- Audio that is fine on quiet speech and breaks up on peaks.
- Distortion that gets worse when you turn something up, and does not improve when you turn the speaker or the far-end volume down.
- A buzz or splatter on a transmitted signal, where the microphone path or the modulation is overdriven.
Do not confuse it with the digital artifacts of the radio's voice coder (warbling, robotic voice, dropouts), which are a different problem: see digital-radio-audio-artifacts. Low signal or network packet loss (latency-jitter-and-packet-loss-in-voice-networks) can also sound distorted, but those problems are not related to level.
Where clipping happens in a radio system
Clipping can happen at any stage that has a ceiling. Walk the path from the source to the listener:
- Microphone or microphone input. Line-level audio fed into a microphone input overloads the first stage; that is harsh even with the level control turned down. Use an attenuation pad (audio-levels-and-radio-interfacing).
- Radio accessory connector or control-station audio output. A fixed or adjustable audio output set too high.
- Gateway or interface input. Where audio enters the digital system (roip-radio-over-ip). Some gateways provide an input level control and some do not; where there is none, the level has to be set in the radio instead.
- Sound card, USB headset or PC audio settings. Microphone boost or an input slider at maximum, or software "enhancements".
- Recorder inputs. A logging recorder fed above its input range clips every recording, and nothing can fix it later.
- The transmitter. An FM transmitter limits deviation. If the microphone audio is too high, the radio's limiter works constantly and the transmitted audio is distorted and wider than it should be.
A clipped signal stays clipped through everything after it: turning it down later makes it quieter, not cleaner. Fix it at the first stage that clips.
Where the level is set on a RadioPro system
The RadioPro IP Gateway has no audio level or gain setting. There is none in the IP Configuration Utility (ICU), whose tabs are General, License Key, Client Accounts, Network, Radio Aliases, the radio-specific settings and Voice Recorder (radiopro-ip-gateway-installation-and-configuration). "Turn the gateway gain down" is not a step that exists. The level is set in two other places:
- In the radio's own programming software. For Kenwood NEXEDGE that is the FPU: the installation guide sets Mic Sense to 4 dB (High) on the AUX tab and the DEO level (the level into the computer) to +5 on the Mobile Function tab, and says the DI and DEO levels may be adjusted as needed (radiopro-ip-gateway-with-kenwood-nexedge). For MOTOTRBO it is the rear mic gain in CPS (radiopro-ip-gateway-with-motorola-mototrbo).
- At the client. The Mic slider and its VU meter in RadioPro Dispatch (radiopro-dispatch-voice-dispatching), or the microphone gain and automatic gain control in RadioPro Talk (radiopro-talk-mobile-app).
How to find the stage that clips
- Use a meter at each stage. Radio and dispatch software usually has one. In RadioPro Dispatch the microphone level shows on a Volume Unit (VU) meter on the toolbar next to the Mic slider. The user guide says that for the best sound level the meter should reach into the yellow area for about 10 to 50% of the duration, and that the red area indicates clipping and distortion and should be avoided. Adjust the Mic slider to suit (radiopro-dispatch-voice-dispatching).
- Start at the source and work toward the listener. Feed in a steady tone, or have the same person speak at their loudest, and note the meter at each point. The first meter that shows red, or a clip light, is the problem stage.
- Reduce gain at that stage, not later. Turn down the output of the stage before it, or the input gain of the stage that is clipping.
- Re-test with the loudest realistic input, such as a loud talker close to the microphone, not just a normal voice.
Setting levels
- Leave headroom: set levels so normal speech peaks well below the ceiling, and loud speech still stays below it. As a common practice, aim for peaks that reach roughly −12 to −6 dBFS on a digital meter. That leaves room for the loudest talker.
- Match level type: microphone level goes to microphone inputs, line level to line inputs (audio-levels-and-radio-interfacing).
- Set the level once, as near the source as the equipment allows, and avoid stacking boosts at several stages.
- Automatic gain control can help with talkers at different distances, but it is not a cure for a stage that is already overloaded.
- Re-check after changing a radio, cable, headset, PC sound setting or gateway.
Quick reference
| Symptom | Likely cause | First thing to try |
|---|---|---|
| Harsh on loud talkers only | Input gain too high, or talker too close | Lower input gain; coach the talker |
| Distorted even on quiet speech | Line level into a mic input, or an output set far too high | Pad or reduce the level at the first stage |
| Recording sounds distorted but the live audio is fine | Recorder input level too high | Lower the level feeding the recorder |
| PC microphone distorted | Microphone boost or input slider at maximum | Lower the Windows or application input level |
| Wider-than-normal or splattered transmission | Overdriven microphone path | Reduce audio into the radio's microphone or line input |
Source documents
This article summarizes the following published CTI Products manuals. They are the authoritative reference.
This article is part of the CTI Products Knowledge Base. Questions about RadioPro or MCN products? Call +1 (513) 595-5900 or email info@ctiproducts.com.
Informational only. This article is general background and is not engineering, safety, legal or regulatory advice. Verify requirements with the equipment manufacturer and the applicable authority before relying on it. Product names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.